I wish I would have skipped the Rodney/Keller on earth episode. I think that's where most of fandom's dislike for her and the pairing came from--that and she replaced Carson....I'm not saying that Rodney doesn't have his problems - I'd be in jail for murder 1 if I had to work for him or tried to date him, but it's more what she's trying to change/asking him to change seems to be so intrinsically Rodney that it shouldn't be changed. But if they're both happy, then so be it. I think Cam or Lorne are a better match for John anyway.